Skip to content
Find my rebates
Free planning tool

Operating Cost Comparison

Compare heat pump and gas heating using your rates and assumptions.

Your result

Let’s run the numbers.

Enter your values, then calculate. No information is sent or saved.

Explore rebate programs →

How this calculator works

Heat pump kWh = annual delivered BTU ÷ (3,412 × COP). Gas therms = annual delivered BTU ÷ (100,000 × efficiency). Each is multiplied by your unit rate. COP 3 and efficiency 90% are editable illustrative assumptions. Fixed charges, cooling, auxiliary heating, equipment and maintenance are excluded.

Full methodology →

How to use the operating cost comparison

  1. Enter your home’s annual heating need in million BTU. An energy audit or your installer can estimate it.
  2. Enter your electricity rate in dollars per kWh. Find it on your bill, or start with your state average in our Electricity Rate Checker.
  3. Enter the heat pump’s seasonal COP (efficiency). The default is 3.
  4. Enter your gas rate in dollars per therm and your furnace efficiency. The default is 90%.
  5. Click Calculate to compare yearly heating energy costs.

Worked example

These are example inputs, not averages. For a home that needs 50 million BTU of heat a year, with electricity at $0.18 per kWh, a COP of 3, gas at $1.50 per therm and a 90% furnace: the heat pump uses about 4,885 kWh (about $879 a year), and the furnace uses about 556 therms (about $833 a year). In this example, gas is about $46 cheaper.

Change electricity to $0.15 and gas to $1.80, and the heat pump becomes cheaper: about $733 versus $1,000. That is why your own local rates matter.

What is not included

  • Monthly fixed charges on your gas and electric bills
  • Cooling costs (heat pumps also cool; a furnace does not)
  • Backup or supplemental heat
  • Equipment, installation and maintenance costs

Related tools

Frequently asked questions

What is COP?

COP (coefficient of performance) is how much heat a heat pump delivers for each unit of electricity it uses. A COP of 3 means 3 units of heat for 1 unit of electricity. Because performance changes over a heating season, use a seasonal average; the U.S. Department of Energy rates seasonal heating efficiency with HSPF.

Where do I find my gas rate per therm?

Divide the gas charges on your bill (without fixed monthly fees) by the therms used. If your bill shows Ccf, the U.S. Energy Information Administration lists 1 Ccf as equal to 1.037 therms.

Will a heat pump lower my bills?

It depends on your local electricity and gas prices, your climate and the equipment. Try your own numbers above.

Sources